Jaguar Land Rover has lost the first round of its intellectual-property fight with BYD over the latter's Ti7 SUV, after a Dutch court ruled that evidence seized in a raid on BYD's European headquarters was unrelated to the copying allegations. The ruling, reported by the Dutch national news agency on November 11 and covered by Chinese outlet NetEase Auto, is procedural and does not decide whether the Ti7 actually copies the Defender.
The Hague court ordered JLR to return or destroy all materials taken from BYD's offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp within 24 hours, and to prevent the data from reaching any third party. Failure to comply would trigger fines of 50,000 euros per hour. The judge also dismissed JLR's request to preserve evidence, noting that the Ti7 has not yet gone on sale in the European Union, so JLR cannot demonstrate harm. JLR was ordered to pay BYD's legal costs of 25,376.57 euros.
The dispute began when JLR accused BYD of copying the Defender's design for the Ti7, which BYD sells overseas as the Ti7. JLR also alleged that BYD dismantled a Defender and reverse-engineered some of its technology for use in the Ti7, leading to a separate copyright lawsuit in Rotterdam. In August, court-authorized bailiffs raided two BYD offices in the Netherlands and copied digital files and paper documents, including Ti7 launch plans, technical data, sensitive financial information, and all materials in BYD's systems related to the Defender.
BYD's legal team called the raid a "fishing expedition," arguing the seizure was overly broad and lacked clear targets. At an October hearing, the core dispute was how the seized digital records could be used and which would be admissible as evidence. JLR also sought a 500,000-euro fine against BYD for allegedly failing to comply with the original seizure order, while BYD argued the seizure itself was excessive.
Presiding judge Hugo van Heemstra sided with BYD, finding that the documents and archives seized from its Dutch offices went beyond the scope of the copying allegations. BYD responded that overseas IP enforcement must match the scope of evidence to the product market and claims, and reaffirmed its commitment to independent research and development while respecting intellectual-property laws.
Ti7's European launch looms
The ruling comes as BYD prepares to bring the Ti7 to Europe. The seven-seat electric SUV is scheduled to launch in the UK in January and is already open for orders in Europe at a starting price of 47,995 pounds (about 430,000 yuan, or roughly $60,500 at current exchange rates). That is a Chinese guide price before taxes and incentives. For comparison, the seven-seat Land Rover Defender 110 starts at 68,465 pounds in the UK (about 610,000 yuan, or $85,900), a gap of more than 20,000 pounds (about 180,000 yuan).
The Defender is JLR's best-selling model and a major profit contributor. While the Defender carries a luxury-brand heritage and hardcore off-road capability, the Ti7 offers a more advanced smart cabin and new-energy powertrain, plus a price about 20,000 pounds lower, which could draw some Defender buyers away.
Foreign media analysis suggests JLR's lawsuit may be an attempt to block the Ti7 from entering Europe. However, given the procedural setback and the difficulty of proving reverse-engineering claims, the cases in The Hague and Rotterdam are unlikely to conclude before the Ti7's January UK launch. The ruling does not address the core question of whether the Ti7's design infringes on the Defender's, leaving that for the substantive proceedings.